'We knew Christmas before you' - the Band Aid fallout
AFPForty years on from the original recording, the cream of British and Irish pop music past and present are once again asking whether Ethiopians know it is Christmas.
In 1984, responding to horrific images of the famine in northern Ethiopia broadcast on the BBC, musicians Bob Geldof and Midge Ure corralled some of the biggest stars of the era to record a charity song.
The release of the Band Aid single, and the Live Aid concert that followed eight months later, became seminal moments in celebrity fundraising and set a template that many others followed.
Do They Know It’s Christmas? is back on Monday with a fresh mix of the four versions of the song that have been issued over the years.
But the chorus of disapproval about the track, its stereotypical representation of an entire continent - describing it as a place "where nothing ever grows; no rain nor rivers flow" - and the way that recipients of the aid have been viewed as emaciated, helpless figures, has become louder over time.
"To say: 'Do they know it’s Christmas?’ is funny, it is insulting," says Dawit Giorgis, who in 1984 was the Ethiopian official responsible for getting the message out about what was happening in his country.
His incredulity decades on is obvious in his voice and he remembers how he and his colleagues responded to the song.
"It was so untrue and so distorted. Ethiopia was a Christian country before England… we knew Christmas before your ancestors," he tells the BBC.
But Mr Dawit has no doubt that the philanthropic response to the BBC film, by British journalist Michael Buerk and Kenyan cameraman Mohamed Amin, saved lives.
Getty ImagesAs the head of Ethiopia's Relief and Rehabilitation Commission he had managed to smuggle the TV crew into the country. This was despite the government at that time, which was marking 10 years of Marxist rule and fighting a civil war, not wanting news of the famine to get out.
"The way the British people responded so generously strengthened my faith in humanity," he says, speaking from Namibia where he now works.
He praises the "young and passionate people" behind Band Aid - describing them as "amazing".
His questioning of the song, whilst also recognising its impact, sums up the debate for many who might feel that when lives need to be saved the ends justify the means.
Geldof was typically robust in defending it responding to a recent article in The Conversation about the "problematic Christmas hit".
"It’s a pop song [expletive]… The same argument has been made many times over the years and elicits the same wearisome response," he is quoted as saying.
"This little pop song has kept hundreds of thousands if not millions of people alive."
He also recognises that Ethiopians celebrate Christmas but says that in 1984 "ceremonies were abandoned".
In an email to the BBC, Joe Cannon, the chief financial officer of the Band Aid Trust, said that in the past seven months the charity has given more than £3m ($3.8m) helping as many as 350,000 people through a host of projects in Ethiopia, as well as Sudan, Somaliland and Chad.
He adds that Band Aid’s swift action as a "first responder" encourages others to donate where funds are lacking, especially in northern Ethiopia, which is once again emerging from a civil war.
But this is not enough to dampen the disquiet.
In the last week, Ed Sheeran has said he is not happy about his voice from the 2014 recording - made to raise funds for the West African Ebola crisis - being used as his "understanding of the narrative associated with this has changed".
He was influenced by British-Ghanaian rapper Fuse ODG, who himself had refused to take part a decade ago.
"The world has changed but Band Aid hasn’t," he told the BBC’s Focus on Africa podcast this week.
"It’s saying there’s no peace and joy in Africa this Christmas. It’s still saying there’s death in every tear," he said referring to the lyrics of the 2014 version.
"I go to Ghana every Christmas… every December so we know there’s peace and joy in Africa this Christmas, we know there isn’t death in every tear."
Fuse ODG does not deny that there are problems to be resolved but "Band Aid takes one issue from one country and paints the whole continent with it".
The way that Africans were portrayed in this and other fundraising efforts had had a direct effect on him, he said.
When growing up "it was not cool to be African in the UK… [because of] the way that I looked, people were making fun of me", the singer said.
Research into the impact of charity fundraisers by British-Nigerian King’s College lecturer Edward Ademolu backs this up.
He himself remembers the short films shot in Africa by Comic Relief, which had been influenced by Band Aid, and that his "African peers at [a British] primary school would passionately deny their African roots, calling all Africans - with great certainty - smelly, unintelligent and equated them to wild animals".
Images of dangerously thin Africans became common currency in efforts to elicit funds.
The cover for the original Band Aid single, designed by pop artist Sir Peter Blake, features colourful Christmas scenes contrasted with two gaunt Ethiopian children, in black and white, each eating what looks like a life-saving biscuit.
For part of the poster for the Live Aid concert the following year, Sir Peter used a photograph of the back of an anonymous, naked, skeletal child.
That image was used again in the art work for the 2004 release and it has appeared once more this year.
For many working in the aid sector, as well as academics who study it, there is shock and surprise that the song and its imagery keep coming back.
The umbrella body Bond, which works with more than 300 charities including Christian Aid, Save the Children and Oxfam, has been very critical of the release of the new mix.
"Initiatives like Band Aid 40 perpetuate outdated narratives, reinforce racism and colonial attitudes that strip people of their dignity and agency," Lena Bheeroo, Bond’s head of anti-racism and equity, said in a statement.
Geldof had previously dismissed the idea that Band Aid's work was relying on "colonial tropes".
The way that charities raise funds has undergone big changes in recent years.
Getty ImagesWhile remaining critical, Kenyan satirist and writer Patrick Gathara, who often mocks Western views of Africa, agrees things have shifted.
"There has been a push within humanitarian agencies to start seeing people in a crisis first as human beings and not as victims, and I think that’s a big, big change," he tells the BBC.
"In the days of Live Aid, all you really had were these images of starvation and suffering… the idea that these are people were incapable of doing anything for themselves and that was always a misconception."
The fallout from the Black Lives Matter protests added impetus to the change that was already happening.
A decade ago, a Norwegian organisation Radi-Aid made it its mission to highlight the way that Africa and Africans were presented in fundraising campaigns using humour.
For example, it co-ordinated a mock campaign to get Africans to send radiators to Norwegians who were supposedly suffering in the cold.
In 2017, Sheeran himself won one of their "Rusty Radiator" awards for a film he made for Comic Relief in Liberia in which he offered to pay for some homeless Liberian children to be put up in a hotel room.
The organisers of the awards said "the video should be less about Ed shouldering the burden alone but rather appealing to the wider world to step in".
University of East Anglia academic David Girling, who once wrote a report for Radi-Aid, argues that its work is one of the reasons that things have shifted.
More and more charities are introducing ethical guidelines for their campaigns, he says.
"People have woken up to the damage that can be caused," he tells the BBC.
Prof Girling’s own research, carried out in Kibera, a slum area in Kenya’s capital, Nairobi, showed that campaigns involving and centred on those who are the targets of the charitable assistance could be more effective than the traditional top down efforts.
Many charities are still under pressure to use celebrities to help raise awareness and money. The professor says that some media outlets will not touch a fundraising story unless a celebrity is involved.
But work by his colleague Martin Scott suggests that big stars can often distract from the central message of a campaign. Whereas the celebrity might benefit, the charity and the understanding of the issue that it is working on lose out.
If a Band Aid-type project were to get off the ground now it would have to be centred on African artists, music journalist Christine Ochefu tells the BBC.
"The landscape for African artists and African music has changed so much that if there was a new release it would need to come from Afrobeats artists or amapiano artists or Afro-pop artists," she argues
"I don’t think people could get away without thinking about the sentiment and imagery associated with the project and it couldn’t continue the saviour narrative that Band Aid had."
As King's College academic Dr Ademolu argues: "Perhaps it's time to abandon the broken record and start anew - a fresh tune where Africa isn’t just a subject, but a co-author, harmonising its own story."
You may also be interested in:
Getty Images/BBCGo to BBCAfrica.com for more news from the African continent.
Follow us on Twitter @BBCAfrica, on Facebook at BBC Africa or on Instagram at bbcafrica